In RA Format
In RA Format
Licitra sings la forza del destino in Vienna
March 15th, 2008. Salvatore Licitra, who is Alvaro in the new Vienna Staatsoper
production of La forza del destino, is quite certainly the worst pusher I've
ever heard, not only on stage, but in my entire record collection included.
He is not pushing like, say, Carreras, when he's getting into trouble
(high notes, loud notes, high loud notes...). He is ALWAYS pushing. Middle
register, low register, not to mention the upper register, loud notes,
soft notes... the voice is so ill-placed, it's really hard to believe.
It goes without saying that this "method" of singing leads to early
exhaustion in a difficult part like Alvaro; and while one of the best
features of this new production is that they're performing the usually
omitted duet "Sleale! Il segreto fu dunque violato", it's doubtable whether
this is REALLY an advantage if Licitra is singing. His top notes in this
scene were not just, like the rest of his performance, bordering on the
comical. They were actually arousing pity. Add his ungainly stage play,
and you have a comic tenor par excellence. (
In favour of the Staatsoper, it should be added that almost everybody
else was way better in this production, even Zubin Mehta. Which is a
proof that it wasn't that tough to be better than Licitra,
I wish to thank Robert Schlesinger for the recording (Gioconda) and review.
I wish to thank Thomas Silverbörg for the picture.
Go back to Index